Monday, February 16, 2009

Their Eyes Were Watching God ch19-20

Through out the entire book, Janie is quick to talk; however, she says almost nothing during the trial.  Why?

Janie's journey is completed in this last chapter as Tea Cake dies, in my perspective. She has been able to achieve her goals of a truly loving relationship, a strong and independent nature and also, a strong and free voice. Tea Cake gave her mutual respect and loved her, as he gave the ultimate price of sacrifice for her. More importantly however, Tea Cake was able to incite and allow her to be strong and autonomous more than any other man she had been with. 
When Tea Cake is sick, we see this female dominance in her as she tries to comfort Tea Cake. "Tea Cake began to cry and Janie hovered him in her arms like a child." (p.211)
With this developed sense of potency, came her free voice. She realizes now that she is able to speak for herself, and she does so. Yet with such a gift, one must find maturity to use it when appropriate. In this situation I think she gave up what she could of her, to pay respect to Tea Cake. 
The shooting and the trail represent the final step in Janie's transformation I think because they showed her true love for Tea Cake and the mastery of her new found voice. Also, they proved her dominance as she was able to control the murder situation and it's outcome.
Janie's journey is now complete because of Tea Cake, and when she returns home and goes upstairs at the end of the book, she states that she will, once again, have a new beginning. "Now, in her room, the place tasted  fresh again. The window... had broomed out all the fetid feeling of absence and nothingness." (p.227)

3 comments:

Elias Reisman said...

I didn't think of it the way you did, with the idea that Janie was only able to speak because Tea Cake was the only one that enabled and encouraged her to use her voice, but I liked it. I think that is a very good reason that Janie didn't speak much at the trail. Nice blog

Abbey S. said...

Great job Ashley!! I think you had a great detailed summary of why Janie did not say much during the trail. I liked how you provided quotes from the text as well. I also agree that Tea Cake respected Janie and "gave the ultimate price of sacrifice for her." With Tea Cake's help, Janie was finally able to find her inner voice.

n00b said...

As Eli said I didn't look at this in the way that you did, but that's not a bad thing. In fact, it's good because you made me look at the ending with different eyes. I didn't think about her goals she had and the maturity she developed. I figured she was quiet because of her grieving, but as you stated, it was also because of her maturity in knowing when to use your voice. With that mind, very good blog!!