Why doesn’t Esther like Dr. Gordon? Is he hurting or helping her?
Esther's insanity has reached quite the repulsive level. She has found the most basically necessary things to live in society, trivial! It is truly revolting that she has gone 3 weeks without fulfilling proper hygiene, or even slept.
When she meets the doctor, she feels utterly distrustful towards him. It seems as though she is looking for someone who would be able to relate to her distress, and not represent someone who she is striving to be. Again the idea of a perfect, focused and drawn out life stands before Esther (the doctor), and this is why she is angered with him. Basically he represents what she is failing to obtain in life right now.
We learn something about her condition when she explains the facileness she has reading the little introductions to larger bodies of writing. It is as if she can only handle the things that are put out there for her, and once there is a smaller, or more intricate text or meaning, she is lost. This is like her view of sex in my opinion. Because once se experienced rape, she was shown that there is more to people being divided up into the sex, and virgin groups.
When she goes back to the psychiatrist the next week, she tells him that she feels unaltered and she is given the solution of shock therapy. In my opinion this type of treatment is barbaric yet at this time in history, there could possibly not have been a better remedy. I think the doctor did not engage himself in her problems enough, maybe finding that she is beyond the point of him help, hence making him think shock therapy is the best answer.
Seeing that his one treatment only made her feel physical pain, I do not think that helped her in the slightest. Actually, it made her distain from returning to the doctor for help later on.

No comments:
Post a Comment