Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Johnny Got His Gun I.ix-x

What does Joe believe is worth fighting for?  What is not worth it?
Joe has just come out of a memory with his father. It was one about his last trip that he would be able to have with his father because the next summer he would be going off camping with his friends. We learn from these types of memories, that these are the types of things he reveres in life. The little moments are what makes Joe so happy and that plays into what he talks about concerning the war.
In part I.x, Joe talks about a few concepts that come up when in time of war. Questions like what are we fighting for? what exactly is fighting for liberty and freedom?, and is it worth the lives of so many for this cause when you are not able to live to prosper from your hard work? 
Joe finds that to some, the goal and drive to fight, is not fully clear. Joe says that he regrets not actually seeing a strong 'tangible' purpose for fighting in the war. He explains that he is confused as to whether the people get actual recognition for their work, or if the idea of having a war is merely to make the US look strong when compared to the foreign countries. 
He talks about how when people were called into the army, they were bribed with many different things. The army used such enticements as, saying that girls were in danger, so they had to go. Then he goes into talking about the sayings of 'dying for liberty' and 'dying for freedom'. He does not understand how someone could die righteously for that type of a cause if they are not even able to feel good about having won the battle, if they are dead. And maybe the people who died in the war did not have the same idea of having freedom and liberty as seen from a war perspective. Maybe their idea of freedom would be to go home and be with their loved ones, and dying like that on the battle field would not be what they wanted.
The the idea that people dying for liberty, honor, and freedom, he says is pointless, because you would not be able to live in the freedom you have created, or the liberty you have permitted so many to have. He actually says "there's nothing noble about dying" (p.148). This having been said, the only thing that Joe feels is worth fighting and risking your life for, is to protect yourself.  

No comments: