Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Johnny Got His Gun I.i-I.iii

What is Joe’s situation?  Why does he compare it to drowning?

We first are introduced to Joe in a memory. He is thinking back to the horrible time when his father died, and we learn about his other family members as well. He has a sister and a mother, and they were all crying and upset about their loved one dying. 
Then we pop back into reality to find that Joe is in the hospital covered in bandages. He has just come back from the war and he was so badly injured from an explosion, that he became deaf and continuously falls unconscious from the pain he was enduring.  Sadly however, he is actually thankful that he would not have to hear the sounds of war anymore, which tells us just how brutal Joe's experiences were in the war! 
Through the text and the flow of the story, we find that his mind is floating in and out of consciousness and that is what makes him feel like he is drowning and blind. He is unable to grasp his realities for long before going back into a memory. These memories he has reminds me of the flashbacks one might have before dying. When your whole life flashes before your eyes, and to remember your past.He explains this sensation of drifting/floating in and out of consciousness, as drowning. He comes up to the 'surface' as he comes to the present time, and then once he moves back into a memory, it is as if he is underwater.
He expresses his desire to die while lying in the hospital, because he has lost so much from the war. They even had to cut off one of his arms, and he now feels useless and too unimportant to live. There is nothing that Joe can do to go back and change his circumstances now, and as he lies in the hospital, all he is doing is remembering how his life had been before the war. 

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

The Bell Jar ch.19-20

Why does Esther feel such a need to sleep with Irwin?  Does she feel better or different after it has happened?

In this part of the novel, Esther is given more freedom to roam around, along with her friend Joan who actually now has an apartment. With this new liberation, Esther is given town leave, and while in town, she happens upon a young professor on the steps of Harvard. They go have coffee and then go back to his apartment to drink a bit. Then later, once they had gone out to dinner and returned to his apartment, Esther feels the need to have her "proper" sexual experience. One that would 'rejuvenate' and enlighten her, with this new understanding of the world. She thinks that this will help her feel better and therefore, in some ways 'cure' her severe disorder. 

She does put more thought into the reasons for having sex with Irwin, where as before she acted desperately; trying to find whom ever, as if she was on a rampage to have sex. She explains that she thinks Irwin would be a good person to sleep with because he is smart, experienced, and she wants more of a dispassionate and neutral affair, which she feels Irwin will give her. One that is"impersonal" and "priest like official”. 

Once she realizes that this fantasized image of sex was not true at all, she feels extreme displeasure. The experience was actually physically hurting her more than it was mentally. Not only did she come to the realization that her whole prospect of 'wonderful knowledge coming from sex' was false, but she also started hemorrhaging. Joan helps rush her to the hospital, where they take care of the problem, but her mental state was left just as skewed, and maybe more so than before. She had expected to find answers to her taunting questions by having sex, but all she got were more questions, along with another trip to a hospital. 

Tuesday, April 28, 2009

The Bell Jar ch.17-18

What does Esther mean when she says she feels trapped under a bell jar?

“I would be sitting under the same glass bell jar, stewing in my own sour air” - page 185
Esther feels that her condition is inescapable. She has truly let herself go into the mental state of confusion beyond her own control, hence her going to the mental hospital. She has spent this whole novel uncertain about the path she wishes to take. She does not know what she wants to do with her life, whether it be becoming an author or traveling to Europe. She also developed this convoluted idea that she could divide the entire population into virgins and those who have had sex. Once she finds there to be smaller intricacies to that idea however, (like rape) this makes her state of perception to be even more skewed. Therefore, in not being able to fully comprehend herself and her needs, this makes it all the more difficult to understand the outside world! This is what makes her develop this 'bell jar' that has been placed over her head. She is not able to escape the bewilderment that makes up her life, because that is her life, and her bewilderment is the 'bell jar'.

This 'bell jar' follows her everywhere, and at one point after her shock therapy, once she was able to go outside, she explained her emotions when the case had been lifted off for a moment in time. This seems to me, to be a very significant point in the novel, because here she demonstrates a hopeful change. She does however, return to seeing her old wishes of suicide, which puts the cover back over her, and her world. 


Sunday, April 26, 2009

The Bell Jar ch.15-16

Describe the new asylum Esther goes to?  What might life have been like had she been forced to stay where she was?
It is interesting that Mrs. Guinea is the person who supports Esther financially, in going to the new mental institution. We find out that she too had once been to such a place, and hence she somewhat understood Esther's emotions on a more intimate level. Just another side note; I think this is the first time that Esther talks about the bell jar, and being trapped in it.
To diverge back on course, once Esther had been moved to the new institution, she is once again treated like an infant. However at the new asylum, there are notable differences. First of all, it is a more wealthy place, and potentially therefore, more opulent. Also, the care she gets there is different, and even though the nurses and others still annoy Esther, it is not to the same extent. 
At one point while at the new institution, she is told that there would be no more visitors, which pleases Esther greatly. She is obviously very strange and did not like people giving her hope and trying to tell her that her condition was all a state of mind and nothing more. 
Her doctor Nolan is also very instrumental in pointing out differences between the two institutions. She actually tries to listen to Esther and in doing so, gain her trust. This is very different from Dr. Gordon who did not talk to her much before resulting to shock therapy.
If she had to stay at the other hospital, she would have continued to be annoyed with the visitors and nurses, along with the uncaring doctors. This would have made her angry, and thus more insane. Also, with having to potentially go through the shock therapy that did not seem to help, all things offered at the other institution would have crippled her more. 

Thursday, April 23, 2009

The Bell Jar ch.13-14

What is wrong with Esther?  Why does she try to kill herself?

Because of all the events that have taken place in the book, they have all compiled on her now and she has lost all her integrity. She has only proven to herself, that the paths she has chosen to follow, have been dead ends, or ones that have come to a fork in the road where she has had to make the decision on which way to go. Her settlements about certain things are never clear, hence this makes her lost. And once she is lost, she becomes confused and scared, resulting finally in a sense of disturbance in not being able to find her way. Through things like her not getting into the writing course she wanted, along with her almost being raped, her vision of life has been distorted. She had these two things to look forward to in her future she thought; to have pleasurable sex that would give her experience, and the writing course that she wanted to do once she got back from the internship. All failed however. She then tries to see the psychiatrist about her situation, and she is not able to get help there either. No one is holding out a hand to help her up. Ironically her suicide plan to drown herself, resembles her situation now, where people are letting her fall down deeper into a crater. Her depression is severe and that is the problem. The depression though is caused by the past events recounted in the novel. She does not see any reason for living, and no one has tried to show her a positive outlook on her situation, not even her mother. The soul figure she truly has, has given up on her. She possibly sees no potential for her daughter, because Esther is not particularly good with getting guys, and to be able to be well off in society of the 50s, a woman needs to find a husband, which she lacks. 

Wednesday, April 22, 2009

The Bell Jar ch.11-12

Why doesn’t Esther like Dr. Gordon?  Is he hurting or helping her?

Esther's insanity has reached quite the repulsive level. She has found the most basically necessary things to live in society, trivial! It is truly revolting that she has gone 3 weeks without fulfilling proper hygiene, or even slept. 
When she meets the doctor, she feels utterly distrustful towards him. It seems as though she is looking for someone who would be able to relate to her distress, and not represent someone who she is striving to be. Again the idea of a perfect, focused and drawn out life stands before Esther (the doctor), and this is why she is angered with him. Basically he represents what she is failing to obtain in life right now. 
We learn something about her condition when she explains the facileness she has reading the little introductions to larger bodies of writing. It is as if she can only handle the things that are put out there for her, and once there is a smaller, or more intricate text or meaning, she is lost. This is like her view of sex in my opinion. Because once se experienced rape, she was shown that there is more to people being divided up into the sex, and virgin groups. 
When she goes back to the psychiatrist the next week, she tells him that she feels unaltered and she is given the solution of shock therapy. In my opinion this type of treatment is barbaric yet at this time in history, there could possibly not have been a better remedy. I think the doctor did not engage himself in her problems enough, maybe finding that she is beyond the point of him help, hence making him think shock therapy is the best answer.
Seeing that his one treatment only made her feel physical pain, I do not think that helped her in the slightest. Actually, it made her distain from returning to the doctor for help later on. 

Tuesday, April 21, 2009

The Bell Jar ch9-10

How does Esther act when she returns to Boston?  How might her night with Marco have influenced her actions?
Marco acted very forcefully the whole night that she was with him. Unfortunately for her, this was her last day in New York, and she was foist to acting sexually with Marco. He tried to rape her that night, and once he insulted her, she punched him in the nose, and it started to bleed. He proceeded to smear it on her face as they fought on the ground. Once she was freed, she ran back to the apartment to pack up and leave the next morning for Boston. That was her last experience before returning home, and therefore this image of desired sex, was corrupted with the image of sexual assault. When she got home, she was stagnant, and did not even really leave her house. She simply fiddled around at home, trying to find things to occupy her time.
Her integrity had vanished once and for all at this point I believe. She saw in herself, no true reason for doing some of the things she wanted to do. For example when she returned home, later that day, she started jumping from one possible activity to another, to involve herself in. She thought about going to Germany, starting a book, writing a thesis... and nothing was truly 'set' from these ideas. This new manner of hers seems to be caused by her experience with Marco, and she tries to clear her mind of that by filling it with other thoughts.
She had based the world on two types of people; virgins, and those more experienced. Through this, I think she was beginning to see what lies on the other side of her misconception. She was confused because her vision of sex was not really portrayed with Marco, and that skewed her perception of sex, and therefore that experience.